When visiting Vietnam, I noticed this.

It’s a water tank on top of a roof. It’s for water pressure. When I scanned along the skyline, every rooftop had one. You can zoom in on this next photo and find them all.

It turns out that Vietnam’s municipal water system generally operates at relatively low pressure. So individual buildings often have their own pumps and storage tanks, including tanks on their rooftops, to provide adequate water pressure throughout the building.
Think about that. Each building buys its own equipment, pays for the electricity, maintains its own pumps, and eventually replaces everything when it wears out.
In a socialist country, they’ve decided that individual buildings should take responsibility for their own water infrastructure.
Come on, guys. Do we (the United States) have to teach you how to do socialism?
Here’s a water tower in Mesa, Arizona, one of the most politically conservative cities in America.
It just makes sense. One water tower. One shared pumping system. Managed by the community. Everyone gets the water pressure they need. So much more efficient than every building having to purchase, install, maintain, and eventually replace its own pumps and rooftop water tanks.
I’m sure the water tank and pump manufacturers wouldn’t be thrilled about this arrangement, but sometimes individualism and capitalism don’t produce the most sensible solution.
Would the residents of Mesa (or anywhere else in Arizona) really prefer to have every household responsible for its own water infrastructure rather than sharing a community-wide system? I’m doubtful.
Sometimes it just makes sense to do things collectively – to own and manage resources together as a community. Not always, and certainly not everything. But some things.
We already do this quite often in the United States: national defense, policing, waste management, electricity, sewage systems, public education, fire protection, parks and recreation, public transit, and emergency medical services. We also organize collectively through voluntary arrangements such as homeowners associations, community networks, cooperatives, and social or religious organizations.
Technically, a community water tower isn’t socialism. But it’s the kind of collective ownership and management that Americans sometimes label “socialist” when debating public policy.
And that’s what I find interesting. We Americans proudly celebrate individualism and capitalism, yet we regularly embrace collective solutions when they make practical and economic sense.
The point isn’t that government should run everything. It’s that sometimes working together produces a better outcome than everyone trying to solve the same problem individually.
From a business perspective, Vietnam has been full of surprises. Small businesses are everywhere! Street vendors, family-run restaurants, tiny shops, and entrepreneurs seemingly on every corner.
I learned that Vietnam has more than 5 million household businesses—roughly one for every five households. Wait a minute. That’s about the same proportion as in the United States!
But here’s the kicker. In 2026, Vietnam exempted household businesses earning less than approximately $40,000 in annual revenue from personal income tax and VAT. That’s revenue, not profit! Millions of small entrepreneurs can operate without paying these major taxes.
At this point, I have to ask Vietnam: Do you guys know what it means to be a socialist country?
We fought a bloody war here. Americans, in large part, to prevent the spread of communism. And the Vietnamese, for various reasons, but also for the ideals of communism.
You won the war. But looking at Vietnam’s thriving private businesses and market-driven economy today, I have to wonder: Is this what you envisioned?
And perhaps there’s an even more uncomfortable question for Americans. If we’d known back then what Vietnam would eventually become (a thriving culture of entrepreneurship), would we still have sent so many of our children here to fight and die?
Which brings me to another question: How committed are we really to opposing socialism?
We certainly talk a good game. We throw around the “S-word” like it’s a venereal disease whenever someone brings up universal healthcare or expanding public services. The mere suggestion of collective responsibility can send people running for the ideological exits.
Yet, as our water towers demonstrate, we already embrace collective solutions when they make practical and economic sense.
So perhaps it’s time to stop using “socialism” as a boogeyman to shut down conversations before they even begin.
Instead of arguing over labels, shouldn’t we be developing thoughtful criteria for deciding when individual ownership and competition work best as well as when collective action makes more sense?
After all, the real question shouldn’t be whether an idea sounds socialist or capitalist – It should be whether it’s a good idea.
It should be whether it’s a good idea.
So When Does Collectivism Actually Make Sense?
Here’s my proposal. Rather than arguing about whether something is socialist or capitalist, let’s ask whether it meets any of these six criteria:
1. Natural monopolies — When competition doesn’t make practical sense.
Think water from the Colorado River, municipal water pipes, electrical grids, or fiber-optic networks to our homes.
Do we really want five competing companies digging up our streets to install five separate sets of water pipes? Sometimes having one shared system is simply more practical and economical.
But here’s the problem: when competition isn’t practical, customers can end up with very little choice.
Many of us know what it’s like to deal with a cable or internet provider like Comcast when there are few meaningful alternatives. Without competition, what keeps a monopoly accountable?
Would we rather have an essential service controlled by a corporation whose primary incentive is maximizing profits? Or a system governed by the people it serves, where the priorities are affordability, reliability, and customer service?
Neither arrangement guarantees good results. But when competition can’t keep providers accountable, perhaps we need another way to ensure they’re serving the community’s interests.
2. Economies of scale — When doing something together costs less than doing it separately.
A community water tower is a perfect example. Why should a thousand households each purchase and maintain their own water infrastructure when they can share the cost of one system?
Of course, bigger isn’t always better. But when sharing resources reduces the total cost for everyone, collective solutions deserve serious consideration.
3. Externalities — When our individual decisions affect other people.
Pollution, public health, overfishing, and shared irrigation systems are good examples.
If a factory dumps waste into a river, the people downstream pay the price. If everyone takes as many fish as they want, eventually there may be no fish left for anyone.
And yes, even that neighbor who hasn’t mowed his lawn in three years might qualify.
The point is that individual freedom sometimes comes with costs that other people are forced to bear. When that happens, communities have a legitimate reason to establish common rules, fund initiatives, and enforce.
4. Public goods — When everyone benefits, even if not everyone pays.
Do we really want each household hiring its own police force, administering its own justice system, or building a flood barrier around just its own property?
Some services are difficult to provide individually because the benefits extend to the entire community. National defense is perhaps the clearest example.
When everyone benefits and it’s difficult to exclude people who don’t contribute, voluntary individual action may not provide enough of the service.
5. Risk pooling — When sharing risks protects us all from catastrophe.
This one is particularly interesting to me.
Everyone wants help when disaster strikes. Nobody particularly enjoys paying premiums when everything is going fine.
But what if a flood destroys your house? Or you develop a serious illness? Or a natural disaster devastates an entire neighborhood?
Most of us couldn’t afford to absorb those losses alone. By pooling risks across many people, we can provide protection that would be prohibitively expensive (or impossible) for individuals to provide themselves.
Remember those “death panels” Sarah Palin was screaming about. The real arguments got lost because of clever name-calling.
The reality is that healthcare resources are limited. Someone has to make decisions about which treatments are covered, under what circumstances, and at what cost. Those decisions exist whether healthcare is financed privately or publicly.
In a private insurance system, companies like UnitedHealthcare make coverage decisions while operating under financial incentives to control costs and earn profits.
In a publicly financed system, coverage policies are shaped through public institutions, laws, budgets, and medical guidelines.
Neither system makes the difficult choices disappear.
But here’s a question worth asking: Would we rather have those decisions governed primarily by corporate financial incentives, or through institutions accountable to the public?
And regardless of which system we choose, shouldn’t we demand transparency, medical evidence, fair appeals processes, and accountability?
Perhaps the more useful debate isn’t whether government or private insurance is inherently better. It’s how we create a system that aligns its incentives with the interests of the people who depend on it.
6. Equity and access — When we believe everyone deserves a basic opportunity or level of protection.
Most of us agree that children should have access to education regardless of how wealthy their parents are.
We don’t want elderly people starving in the streets or sick people dying simply because they can’t afford medical care.
We may disagree passionately about how much support society should provide, who should pay for it, and how it should be delivered. Those are important questions.
But the underlying principle is that we sometimes value a basic level of opportunity, dignity, and security for everyone—even when providing it requires us to share the costs.
Now, none of these criteria automatically means government should take over.
And this certainly isn’t a proposal to expand the federal government. I’m talking about something much broader: when does it make sense for an affected community to think and act collectively?
That community might be a neighborhood, a city, a state, a nation, a cooperative, or even a religious organization.
Sometimes collective action means shared ownership. Sometimes it means common rules, shared financing, or simply coordinating our decisions.
And let’s be clear: most things probably shouldn’t be collectively owned or managed.
I don’t want a community committee deciding which laptop I should buy, which restaurant I should eat at, or what color to paint my living room. Individual choice, private ownership, and competition work remarkably well for most things.
But sometimes (and I think we should be willing to admit this) managing something together simply makes more sense.
So instead of arguing about whether an idea is socialist or capitalist, perhaps we should ask a better question:
Is this something individuals can do better on their own, or is it something we can do better together?
A laptop? I’ll choose my own, thank you.
A community water tower? Maybe we should all chip in.
And rather than debating through ideological name-calling and labeling, perhaps we’ll have better outcomes when we argue using reason and logic.